May 14

Viagra Works for the Long Haul

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by jweiss123 | 0 comments


Oct. 21, 2003 (Salt Lake City) — With prostate cancer treatment success often comes at a heavy price: erectile dysfunction. But, a new study shows that Viagra will work in nearly 70% of the men who have radiation-associated erectile dysfunction for years to come.

Michael Zelefsky, MD, of Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, N.Y., tells WebMD that the radiation-associated erectile dysfunction usually “begins about six months after they have concluded therapy, but it can occur at any time during or after treatment.” He says that he has already reported that “about 70% of men initially respond to Viagra. However, they didn’t know if the response would be durable.”

In the new study, which was presented at the 45th Annual Meeting of the American Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology, Zelefsky and his colleagues studied the “” of response by following 360 men with radiation-induced erectile dysfunction who initially responded to the drug. He followed the group for an average of nearly four years after their surgery to see if they were still taking Viagra for erectile dysfunction.

The results, he says, were surprising. “I didn’t really expect them to still be taking the drug and I expected that for many men the effect would diminish with time.” But after almost four years, 96% of the men who initially responded to Viagra were still taking the drug and all but six of those men said the drug was still effective.

All of the men in the study had prostate cancer that was confined to the prostate gland. They received radiation therapy by either external beam treatment or by brachytherapy, in which radioactive “seeds” implanted in the prostate deliver radiation directly to the tumor.

The external radiation is done while the patient lies in a special box that allows multiple radiation beams to be directed directly to the prostate gland from all sides, while the rest of the body is protected from the radiation.

Prostate cancer is mainly found in older men. After prostate cancer has been diagnosed, tests are done to determine if it has spread outside the gland. Because there are different available, how much the cancer has spread this will help in deciding what treatment is best for the cancer.

Surgery to remove the cancer is one option that is used to treat prostate cancer. Radiation is another therapy used in treating this cancer. Erectile dysfunction can occur in men treated with either one of these treatments.

Zelefsky says the men who reported that Viagra stopped working were those who were treated with extremely high-dose external radiation.

Richard Valicenti, MD, associate professor radiation oncology, at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital, in , tells WebMD that the study is “important since it shows that treatment with Viagra can deliver a durable response.” But Valicenti, who wasn’t involved in the study, says that he, too, is a little surprised by the results, especially because of the fairly large range in the length of treatment and because drug tolerance is common.

“We don’t really know how often they are taking the drug. We know that with repeated use tolerance develops for many drugs and we expect it for this drug as well,” he says.

If tolerance does develop, the new erectile dysfunction drug, Levitra, could be an option says Zelefsky. He says his group is a study with this newly approved drug but notes that it will be sometime before the results are available. Meanwhile, he says that he is trying Levitra in men who don’t initially respond to Viagra.

How do yo think, is it true about ?

May 13

Viagra May Help Heal Broken Hearts

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by jweiss123 | 0 comments

Jan. 24, 2005 — A drug commonly used to rev up a man’s love life may also eventually be used to help reverse abnormal growth of the heart, according to a new study in mice.

Researchers found Viagra reversed the abnormal growth of heart muscles and restored normal heart function to mice with enlarged hearts.

“A larger-than-normal heart is a serious medical condition, known as hypertrophy, and is a common feature of heart failure that can be fatal,” says researcher David Kass, MD, professor at The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and its heart institute, in a news release.

The condition often develops as a result of chronically uncontrolled high blood pressure; this forces the heart to pump harder in order to meet the body’s needs. To adapt to these high forces, the muscles of the heart enlarge.

People with hypertrophy or enlarged hearts have a higher risk of developing heart disease, heart failure, or sudden cardiac death.

Researchers say the findings are the first to show that Viagra may be an effective treatment for a chronic heart condition. The next step will be to conduct a study to see if the drug will have the same beneficial effect in humans that it had in mice.

Viagra May Heal Hearts

In the study, which appears in the Jan. 23 online edition of Nature Medicine, researchers conducted several experiments on mice using Viagra.

In the first experiment, researchers induced the enlarged hearts (hypertrophy) in mice by subjecting their hearts to high blood pressure. But they found mice fed Viagra in their food at a dose similar to those used by humans developed hypertrophy at half the rate as mice that ate regular food.

The mice fed Viagra also showed 67% less scarring of heart muscles, a common seen in enlarged hearts. Researchers say the mice that got Viagra had smaller hearts and better heart function than the untreated mice.

In a second test, researchers used the same dose to examine its effects at reversing hypertrophy. The hearts of the mice were exposed to high blood pressure to induce hypertrophy for seven to 10 days, during which they experienced muscle growth and stiffness of nearly 65%.

After two weeks of treatment with Viagra, the muscle stiffness and enlargement almost completely disappeared.

Researchers also found that heart function, which with hypertrophy, improved after the muscle growth had been stopped with Viagra treatment.

“This study shows that sildenafil (Viagra) can make hypertrophy go away,” says Kass. “Overall, the results provide a better of the biological pathways involved in hypertrophy and heart dilation, leading contributors to heart failure. They suggest possible therapies in the future, including sildenafil, which has the added benefit of already being studied as safe and effective for another medical condition.”

Kass says “more study is required before we fully understand the benefits of sildenafil on the heart.”

Read another articles about .

May 12

Jury Still Out on Effectiveness of Viagra for Women

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by jweiss123 | 0 comments

May 24, 2000 (San Francisco) — Don’t expect to see Elizabeth Dole in an ad
for Viagra. Once again, when the miracle drug was tested in women with sexual
dysfunction it failed the test proving, according to some critics, that what is
good for the gander will never fly in the goose.

Nonetheless, Pfizer Pharmaceuticals, the maker of the drug, is not throwing
in the towel. Pfizer tells WebMD that it is forging ahead with a new study that
will test the drug in women on hormone replacement therapy whose
main complaint is the inability to become sexually aroused.

Michael T. Sweeney, MD, medical director of the Viagra team at Pfizer, tells
WebMD that the new study is recruiting 150 women who will either receive a
sugar pill or one of three Viagra doses: 10 mg, 50 mg, or 100 mg.

But Viagra has had some success among women, because if the mass media is
any indication, sexual dysfunction in women is news and much of the credit for
that goes to Viagra, the drug that made it possible to take sexual dysfunction
public. With the remarkable success of Viagra for men with impotence,
hoped that the drug could do the same for women.

But once again, gender makes a difference, says Rosemary Basson, MBBS, MRCP.
Basson was lead researcher of a Canadian and European study of almost 600 women
with sexual dysfunction disorders.

In this latest study, released at a meeting of obstetricians and
gynecologists here this week, the placebo performed better than Viagra
regardless of the dose. , more than a third of women taking higher
doses of Viagra — 50 mg and 100 mg — reported side effects, such as headache
and flushing. Basson says that “is much higher than the rate in men, which
is only about 14% or 15%.” She is associate professor in both obstetrics
and psychiatry at the University of British Columbia and Vancouver
Hospital.

Basson, who says she has been treating sexual dysfunction in women for
decades, says it is difficult to determine if Viagra will ever have a
therapeutic role for women. “Among women, sexual dysfunction is not so
easily divided into different areas as it is with men. In women, it is more of
a continuum in which women may have low desire, female sexual arousal disorder,
or female orgasmic disorder. It is not such a simple thing as blood
supply,” she says.

Picking up that theme, Winnifred Cutler, PhD, president of the Athena
Institute for Women’s Wellness Inc. in Chester Springs, Penn., says sexual
response in women is actually even more complicated than a mixing of the
emotional and physical.

In another presentation at the same meeting, Cutler presented findings that
also suggest hysterectomy may have a negative impact on sexual response in
women. Researchers looked at women who had hysterectomies, women who had not
had hysterectomies, and women who were diagnosed as having fibroid tumors in
the uterus, a common condition. A majority of women in all three groups report
a high rate of sexual satisfaction, she says.

However, says Cutler, more than half of the women “report frequent
orgasm,” but frequency of orgasm declines when a hysterectomy is scheduled.
She says other studies have noted lower levels of orgasm at the time
hysterectomy is scheduled and higher levels at two years after surgery. Those
studies claim, she says, that hysterectomy improves sexual function and
satisfaction.

“Our data suggest that sexual satisfaction is suppressed at the time a
hysterectomy is scheduled,” she says. “The claim that hysterectomy
improves a woman’s sex life is wrong.”

Basson says that Cutler’s theory is interesting, but has some skepticism.
“I think if this were true, I would be getting great numbers of
referrals,” she says. “That is not the case. I am not
treating great numbers of women who say that hysterectomy made them sexually
dysfunctional.”

Vital Information:

  • Viagra has suffered some recent setbacks in studies testing the drug in
    women who have sexual dysfunction.
  • A therapist who works with female patients with sexual dysfunction says
    unlike men, women’s conditions don’t focus on blood flow, but rather, are
    affected by multiple factors.
  • Another factor that can contribute to a woman’s sexual is a
    plan for hysterectomy. While studies have found those who have had this surgery
    often have a satisfying sex life, intimacy often suffers during the time the
    procedure is planned, but gradually recovers.

May 11

Viagra Plus Testosterone Gel May Treat ED Better

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by jweiss123 | 0 comments

Aug. 6, 2004 — Men with low testosterone levels who suffer from erectile and have tried Viagra without success may benefit from adding a testosterone gel to their impotence treatment plan.

Nearly 30% to 50% of men with erectile dysfunction who take Viagra don’t respond adequately to treatment. The reason could be low levels of the sex hormone testosterone, according to a new study published in the Journal of Urology.

Low levels of the hormone could lead to a low sex drive and erectile dysfunction, , fatigue, and osteoporosis in men.

The study tracked 75 men aged 18-80 years old with low levels of testosterone and erectile dysfunction. All the men were in stable, heterosexual and had failed to respond to treatment with 100 milligrams of Viagra.

For 12 weeks, the men took Viagra in combination with either the testosterone gel (AndroGel) or a placebo gel. The gel is applied to the skin and is absorbed slowly resulting in an increased blood level of testosterone. Viagra improves erectile dysfunction without causing an increase in testosterone levels.

Researchers gauged the men’s sexual function, quality of life, and testosterone levels at the start of the survey and every four weeks the study.

The men using the testosterone gel along with Viagra improved in every category. Men receiving testosterone gel reported a 34% improvement in impotence compared with a 17% improvement seen in men taking the placebo gel. They also reported a 28% improvement in orgasmic function compared with only a 4% improvement reported in men taking the placebo.

Overall satisfaction also improved, with men receiving AndroGel reporting a 32% improvement compared with a 10% improvement in overall satisfaction in men on placebo.

The benefits were noted about four weeks into the study.

The conclude that men seeking treatment for erectile dysfunction should be screened for low testosterone before beginning therapy and using testosterone gel along with Viagra may be better for men with erectile dysfunction and low testosterone levels than just taking Viagra alone.

May 9

Viagra Ingredient OK’d for Lung Problem

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by jweiss123 | 0 comments

June 8, 2005 — The FDA has approved Viagra’s active ingredient to treat pulmonary , a rare, life-shortening lung disorder that causes high blood pressure in the lungs.

Viagra’s maker, Pfizer, a WebMD sponsor, announced the approval in a news release. Pfizer will repackage Viagra’s key ingredient (sildenafil) and market it as Revatio.

Revatio would be used to improve exercise ability in patients with pulmonary hypertension, says Pfizer. The approved dose is limited to 20 three times daily. The white, round pills will look different from Viagra’s blue diamonds and should be available by mid-July, says Pfizer.

Rare Condition

Pulmonary hypertension involves dangerously high pressure in the blood vessels that lead from the heart to the lungs. It affects an estimated 100,000 people worldwide, says Pfizer.

Most cases of pulmonary hypertension are due to some condition, such as chronic lung or heart disease. Nearly 300 cases, mostly women in their 30s, are diagnosed per year, says the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI). There is no known cause.

Symptoms include difficulty breathing, dizziness, and fatigue. Without treatment, patients live less than three years from the time of diagnosis, on average, says Pfizer.

Another oral drug, Tracleer, is also used to treat the condition. Revatio’s effectiveness hasn’t been evaluated in patients taking Tracleer, says Pfizer. The drug company says Revatio is the first oral treatment approved for patients with an early stage of the progressive condition.

Study’s Results

The FDA’s approval was based on a study of 277 people with pulmonary hypertension, says Pfizer. Patients were randomly assigned to get a placebo or 20, 40, or 80 milligrams of Revatio three times daily.

After 12 weeks, all three Revatio groups showed “highly significant improvements” in the distance they could walk in six minutes, compared with the placebo group, says Pfizer. Average pressure in the lung arteries and other heart functions also improved with Revatio, and in a year-long trial, 94% of patients taking Revatio were still alive, says Pfizer.

No dose had an advantage, and the lowest dose was approved.

Side Effects

Pfizer says Revatio was generally well tolerated, with side effects similar to those seen with Viagra.

The most common side effects for Revatio were headache, indigestion, flushing, insomnia, and nosebleeds. Viagra’s most common side effects are headache, facial flushing, and upset stomach; less common (and brief) side effects are bluish vision, blurred vision, or sensitivity to light, says Pfizer.

Pfizer also recently said it is talking with the FDA about possible label changes to Viagra regarding extremely rare reports of vision loss.rare reports of vision loss. The drug company says there is no evidence that those rare cases occurred more often in men taking Viagra. Pfizer says no such problems were seen in clinical trials of Viagra, and no cases were noted in the Revatio news release.

Ongoing Care Needed

It’s important to get ongoing medical care for pulmonary hypertension, says the NHLBI. The NHBLI also recommends walking for patients who can do so, as well as eating healthfully, getting enough rest, and not smoking. Relaxation exercises, stress reduction, and a positive attitude may also help patients stay active for as long as possible, says the NHLBI.

May 8

Viagra Works in Women, Too

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by jweiss123 | 0 comments


May 5, 2003 (New Orleans) — Depression takes all the joy out of life, even the joy of sex. for many people, many symptoms of depression diminish once they begin treatment with antidepressant drugs such as Prozac. But for many women, when the depression leaves the sexual dysfunction remains, says H. George Nurnberg, MD, professor of psychiatry at the University of New Mexico.

For these women, he says that Viagra can change their lives.

In fact, he tells WebMD that Viagra is just as good at reversing sexual dysfunction in women as it is in reversing similar symptoms in men.

And he presented his evidence at the 51st annual clinical meeting of the American College of Obstetricians and .

Nurnberg, who has already published a study in the Journal of the American Medical about the efficacy of Viagra in men who have sexual dysfunction associated with treatment for depression, says that 84% of women in his study had a return of sexual enjoyment after treatment with Viagra.

The study enrolled 42 women who had no history of sexual dysfunction before treatment for depression. All of the women were treated with one of the SSRI type of antidepressants such as Prozac or Zoloft, which often have sexual dysfunction as a side effect. All the women were “no longer depressed after being treated with those drugs for six to eight weeks,” he says. But all the women “reported sexual dysfunction related to the SSRI treatment.”

The women are randomly selected to take either Viagra or dummy pills for eight weeks. Neither the women nor the doctors knew which pills the women were getting.

Nurnberg and his colleagues assessed response using a standard psychiatric test designed to measure sexual function. The test, called the Clinical Global Impression-Sexual Function or CGI-SF, scores responses about arousal or sexual satisfaction, using a 1 to 7 rating system, with lower scores indicating better functioning.

At the end of the study, “84% of women had a score of 2 or less,” he says. Moreover, he says that Viagra can be given at the same time as the antidepressant, which might make women “less likely to discontinue antidepressant treatment, which is a real problem since only about 20% of women are willing to stick with a full course of antidepressant therapy.” He says that often this reluctance to stay the course with treatment is related to the sexual dysfunction side effect.

Gerald F. Joseph Jr., MD, medical director of women’s services at St. John’s Health System in Springfield, Mo., tells WebMD that Nurnberg’s results are but he is not entirely sold on Viagra. He says, for example, that “placebo effect is very powerful in studies of sexual dysfunction, and I’m not sure these findings are not really just a placebo effect.”

Joseph, who wasn’t involved in the study, says that as a surgeon he thinks the only way that Viagra could work in women is if the women have sexual dysfunction that is “associated with an abnormality in the erectile tissue present in the genitals. Otherwise, it just doesn’t make sense.”

May 6

Viagra Improves Sex for Some Women

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by jweiss123 | 0 comments

Jan. 7, 2004 — Viagra can do wonders for men. But a new study shows it also improves sex for some postmenopausal women.

The findings come from a research team led by gurus Jennifer R. Berman, MD, and Laura A. Berman, PhD. The placebo-controlled study, funded by Viagra maker Pfizer Inc., evaluated 202 postmenopausal women diagnosed with female sexual arousal disorder (FSAD). This disorder is defined as distress from an inability to attain or maintain sexual excitement.

Half the women were treated with Viagra; the other half got inactive placebo pills. Many of the women who got the placebo reported improved genital sensation. Some even reported more sexual . But both of these were much more common among women who took Viagra.

The little blue pill didn’t work for women who, in addition to FSAD, also had something called hypoactive sexual desire disorder or HSDD. While many women with FSAD have difficulties with genital blood flow — suggesting a physical problem that Viagra can help — women with HSDD may be more likely to have an underlying emotional or relationship problem leading to lack of sexual desire.

“Unresolved emotional or relational issues should be addressed before beginning medical therapies,” Berman and colleagues stress. Their report appears in the December 2003 issue of The Journal of Urology.

Viagra, Genital Sensation, and Sexual Satisfaction

Women were included in the study if they were postmenopausal or if they had a hysterectomy. Their ages ranged from 30 to 71 with an average age of about 51.

The Berman team focused on the women’s answers to two questions after taking Viagra or placebo:

  • After taking the study medication, the sensation/feeling in my genital (vagina, labia, clitoris) area during intercourse or seemed to be: (a) more than before, (b) less than before, or (c) unchanged.
  • After taking the study medication, intercourse and/or foreplay was (a) pleasant and satisfying; better than before taking the study medication; (b) unpleasant; worse than before the study medication; (c) unchanged; no difference; or (d) pleasant but still not like it used to be or I would like it to be.

Among placebo recipients, 44% reported improvement in the first question and 28% reported improvement in the second question.

Among all Viagra recipients, 57% reported improvement in the first question and 42% reported improvement in the second question.

But among Viagra recipients with sexual arousal disorder who did not have HSDD, the results were more striking: 69% reported improvement in the first question. This group was eight times more likely to report improvement than women without HSDD who got placebo.

Similarly, among Viagra recipients with sexual arousal disorder who did not have HSDD 50% reported improvement in the second question. This group was 11 times more likely to report improvement than non-HSDD women who got placebo.

The authors note that women who respond to Viagra may need to have normal levels of estrogen and . For many postmenopausal women, that may mean menopausal replacement therapy. In the present study, the women had normal hormone levels or were receiving menopausal replacement therapy.

SOURCE: Berman, J.R. The Journal of Urology, December 2003; vol 170: pp 2333-2338.

May 5

Viagra May Help Severe Altitude Sickness

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by jweiss123 | 0 comments

Feb. 1, 2005 — A new use for Viagra may be in the works. The erectile drug may help protect against lung problems resulting from high altitudes, say French .

High altitude can cause illness, in people with existing heart and lung problems. The thinner air or lack of oxygen at higher altitudes can cause blood vessels to constrict. When this occurs within the lungs, the constriction of blood vessels can put more force on the heart, leading to life-threatening heart failure. The higher altitude can cause blood vessels in the lung to leak fluid and build up in the lung, with oxygen exchange.

Viagra works by relaxing blood vessels, allowing more blood to flow freely through vessels. The researchers used this drug to block the effects of high altitude on blood vessels on the lung. They looked at whether the use of Viagra would help the lungs continue to get oxygen while ascending to higher altitudes.

In a recent experiment, Viagra was better than a placebo at protecting men’s lungs. The results appear in the February issue of the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine.

This was no ordinary lab test. Instead, 12 men perched on a French mountain about 2.7 miles (4,350 meters) above sea level, pushing their lungs to the limits in the name of science.

The participants were normal, healthy men around 29 years old. They weren’t mountaineers. None was used to high altitudes. The closest any of them had gotten to Mount Everest was probably seeing it in a photo.

But they were in for an adventure when they enrolled in the study.

May 4

Pfizer: Viagra Does Not Raise Blindness Risk

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by jweiss123 | 0 comments

June 28, 2005 — Pfizer officials say they have found no sign of increased
blindness risk in men taking its drug Viagra.

Pfizer staff have reviewed all reports of eye-related events since the drug
has been on the market, according to a news release from the pharmaceutical
company.

“There is no evidence that Viagra causes blindness or any other serious
ocular condition,” says Joseph Feczko, MD, in the news release. Feczko is
Pfizer’s chief medical officer.

Pfizer is a WebMD sponsor.

Rare Vision Problem

“Men taking Viagra are at no greater risk for blindness than men of
similar age and health not taking the medicine,” says Feczko.

That includes a rare vision problem called nonarteritic anterior ischemic
optic neuropathy (NAION), says Feczko. NAION is a painless swelling of the
optic nerve that causes a rapid reduction in vision.

A journal report earlier this year noted
NAION in 14 Viagra users.
Most had other health problems or
eye problems that raised their risk of NAION. None of the men in the
study went blind, although their vision loss was permanent and reportedly
started within 24-36 hours of taking Viagra.

Pfizer: No Evidence Seen in More Than 27 Million Users

“After more than 10 years of rigorous clinical study and worldwide
safety monitoring of a medicine used by more than 27 million men, there is no
evidence to suggest a link between Viagra and blindness or other serious ocular
events,” says Feczko.

“In addition, several studies specifically looking into the effect of
Viagra in the eye by Pfizer as well as independent ophthalmologic experts found
Viagra to have no serious adverse effects on the eye,” he says.

Pfizer, FDA Discussing Label Changes

According to Pfizer’s statement,
the company is still talking to the FDA about changing Viagra’s label to
reflect rare vision problems in men who have used the drug.

The update would reflect rare reports of NAION in some men who have used the
drug.

However, the FDA concluded that no causal relationship between Viagra and
NAION has been established, says Pfizer.

Talks between Pfizer and the FDA were first reported in May.

Label Changes for Other ED Drugs?

Other erectile drugs may also update their labels.

“It is Pfizer’s understanding that the FDA has asked that similar
information be included in the labels of all oral ED (erectile dysfunction)
medicines,” the company’s statement reads.

Patients should consult their doctors about using Viagra and follow the
drug’s information, as with any other medicine, says Pfizer.

Mar 19

Should Insurance Cover Viagra?

Published in Generic Viagra, Erectile Dysfunction Drugs, Viagra, Sildenafil Citrate by | 0 comments

June 19, 2000 — A dollar spent on Viagra is spent just as efficiently as a
dollar spent on kidney dialysis, a new study shows. Experts agree that the math
is right, but whether it justifies insurance coverage for the male potency drug
is a bone of contention.

“There is a significant loss of quality of life that comes from erectile
dysfunction,” the lead researcher of the study, Kenneth J. Smith, MD, tells
WebMD. “One thing that motivated me to look at this is that I am a primary
care doctor. I am seeing men with erectile dysfunction having to fill out
insurance forms to justify Viagra treatment. What prompted the insurance
carriers to set up so many barriers for some men to get Viagra who would
clearly benefit from it? I see Viagra use more as a health issue and a
quality-of-life issue than as a lifestyle issue.”

Smith, who is associate director of the internal medicine residency program
at Mercy Hospital of Pittsburgh, based his calculations on several key
assumptions, such as the average age of the Viagra user and the average number
of times he would use it per month.

Researchers also took into account that this medication would not work for
some men and that some men would have side effects. In every case, they chose
figures that would make it harder to show a cost benefit for the drug. Even so,
Viagra was a good deal when measured in quality years of life gained.

“We used in our baseline analysis a cost of $52 1998 dollars for six
pills per month,” Smith says. “You would need to spend $244 per month
– 20 pills — before Viagra would become cost-ineffective.” The results
were published in this month’s issue of the journal Annals of Internal
Medicine
.

Such figures make Viagra more cost-effective than renal dialysis,
cholesterol-lowering medication, or heart bypass grafting, Smith says. He
admits, however, that unlike these other conditions, erectile dysfunction is
hardly life threatening. But he argues that insurance carriers pay for many
other illnesses — such as migraine headaches — that affect the quality but
not the length of a person’s life.

“It looks like when insurance companies were deciding whether to cover
Viagra, they probably didn’t use a analysis to make the
decision,” he says. “It would appear that their decisions have been
arbitrary.”

In an editorial, Michael R. McGarvey, MD, says Smith and colleagues did
their math the right way. But McGarvey, who is chief medical officer for
Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey, says they drew the wrong
conclusions about what this means for insurance coverage.

“My personal feeling is that we really need to re-examine the whole
issue of what we should be expecting health insurance to do for us,”
McGarvey tells WebMD. “It should be aimed at providing health services that
are of proven value for serious and expensive conditions. We should re-examine
the use of health insurance for that ‘enhance’ our
lives.”

McGarvey says that Americans expect their health insurance to provide more
benefits than ever before. These are partly due to new
technologies, he says — and partly because people fortunate enough to be able
to afford health insurance are getting spoiled.

“I think because insurance has become so incredibly complicated, most
Americans are reasonably confused about the coverage they have and don’t
have,” he says. “The expectation is that it should cover whatever they
want, as often as they want it. Americans tend to have very high expectations
and are very unhappy when these expectations are thwarted in any way.”

McGarvey points out that there is a limit to what insurers can do. At
current rates, one in five Americans will be uninsured by the year 2008. The
question the nation must face, he says, is whether less extensive health
insurance should be given to more people, or more extensive health insurance
should be given to fewer people.

“We are confronting a national embarrassment which is the number of
people that are uninsured,” McGarvey says. “We know health insurance is
an important but increasingly expensive component of our lives. We need to
think about it and exercise some judgement in making and adhering to some
difficult decisions. As you add more and more and more benefits, insurance will
become less and less affordable and people will drop out of the insurance pool.
And that is bad for a growing number of people.”

Smith agrees that McGarvey is raising important questions. “The points
that Dr. McGarvey makes are very good ones — and we are looking at two sides
of the same coin,” he says. “I don’t think that you can base insurance
coverage just on cost-effectiveness. There are other factors. But it should
certainly be a factor.”

Vital Information:

  • New research shows that Viagra is cost-effective for improving quality of
    life, but there is still debate about whether health insurance should pay for
    this drug.
  • One researcher argues that insurance companies pay for treatment of other
    illnesses, such as migraine headaches, that aren’t life threatening, so Viagra
    should be covered as well.
  • Another expert argues that Americans who have health insurance expect too
    much, and that adding more benefits only increases costs, which increases the
    number of uninsured.

See related site about .